About the Menu

Hemingway's Tavern offers a menu that balances familiar American comfort with Caribbean-inspired flavors, creating a relaxed and inviting dining experience. The selection ranges from casual bites like Tavern Smoked Wings and Plantain Chips with House Guacamole to more substantial options such as the Guava Jerk Sirloin and Snapper Hemingway. Desserts, including Key Lime Pie and Cuatro Leches Plantain Bread Pudding, add a sweet touch to any meal.

Whether you're stopping by for a casual lunch, a leisurely dinner, or enjoying a handcrafted Tavern Margarita at the bar, the menu complements the warm, laid-back atmosphere of the restaurant. Light starters like Black Bean Hummus or Cuban Pork Empanadas pair well with easygoing gatherings, while hearty dishes and thoughtfully crafted sides suit those moments when comfort food feels just right.

The variety also extends to thoughtful options for different preferences, including fresh salads, flavorful soups like Conch Chowder, and vibrant vegan choices that keep the menu approachable and inclusive. Overall, the menu captures the spirit of enjoyable everyday moments—food and drinks made to be savored in a comfortable and welcoming space.

Business Menu

SNEAK PREVIEWS
TOSTONES DE CERDO ASADO
US$11.00
BLACK BEAN HUMMUS
US$10.50
CUBAN PORK EMPANADAS
US$11.00
LOBSTER, SPINACH AND ARTICHOKE DIP
US$20.00
YUCA CHEESE BITES
US$8.00
CHARRED OCTOPUS & HASH
US$20.00
TAVERN SMOKED WINGS
US$16.50
CONCH FRITTERS
DRUNKEN SHRIMP COCKTAIL
US$13.00
YARD BIRD ON A STICK
US$12.00
TRUFFLE FRIES
US$12.00
SMOKED FISH DIP
US$12.00
GUCAMOLE & CHIPS
US$13.50
NOTICE:
SOUPS & SALADS
SALAD COMBO
US$12.00
BAHAMIAN CONCH CHOWDER
CARIBBEAN BLACK BEAN SOUP
HOUSE SALAD
WEDGE CAESAR
SPRING SPINACH SALAD
US$16.50
MEDITERRANEAN SALAD
US$18.00
BURGERS
PREMIERE BURGER
US$14.00
GUAVA BBQ BURGER
US$16.00
MUSHROOM SWISS BURGER
US$18.00
HAVANA BURGER
US$17.00
BIG GAME BURGER
US$20.00
GARBANZO BURGER
US$14.50
SANDWICHES
OUR SIGNATURE SANDWICH: PAPA’S CUBAN
PAPA'S CUBAN COMBO
US$14.50
CUBANO DE ROPA VIEJA
US$18.00
CUBANO DE CROQUETA
US$14.00
CUBANO DE LANGOSTA
US$26.00
MOJO PORK GRILLED CHEESE
US$13.00
CAPRESE CHICKEN MELT
US$18.00
MAHI SANDWICH
US$17.50
Island Steak Sandwich
US$21.00
BUFFALO JERK CHICKEN
US$19.00
TROPICAL PORK SANDWICH
US$14.00
MAIN EVENT
KEY WEST BOWL
US$15.50
SNAPPER HEMINGWAY
US$32.00
SANTIAGO'S CATCH
ERNEST'S RIB PLATTER
US$25.00
LOBSTER RAVIOLI
US$27.00
LINGUINI CARBONARA
US$14.50
TAVERN TACOS
US$12.50
GUAVA JERK SIROLIN
US$28.00
VEGETARIAN
CHICKPEA PASTA PRIMAVERA PASTA
US$16.00
GRILLED GARDEN STACK
US$14.00
SIDES
VEGETABLE MEDLEY
US$4.50
TOSTONES
US$4.50
FRENCH FRIES
US$4.50
MADUROS
US$4.50
PLANTAIN CHIPS
US$4.50
YUCA FRIES
US$4.50
GRILLED PINEAPPLE SLAW
US$4.50
BLACK BEANS AND RICE
US$4.50
GARLIC MASHED POTATOES
US$4.50
PREMIUM SIDES
ASPARAGUS
US$6.50
MAC 'N CHEESE
US$6.50
RICE CARIBE
US$6.50
RED BEANS & RICE
US$6.50
PARMESAN GARLIC BROCCOLI
US$6.50
LOADED GARLIC MASHED POTATOES
US$6.50
TRUFFLE FRIES
US$6.50
TRUFFLE YUCA FRIES
US$6.50
H.W.A. SIDES
CHORIZO YUCA HASH
US$10.00
TRI-COLOR SWEET POTATO FRIES
US$8.00
CRISPY BRUSSELS SPROUTS
US$9.00
ISLAND MACARONI SALAD
US$8.00
DESSERTS & COFFEES
KEY LIME PIE
US$8.00
PINEAPPLE UPSIDE DOWN CAKE
US$8.00
ULTIMATE BROWNIE
US$8.00
SWEET PLANTAIN BREAD PUDDING
US$9.00
GUAVA CHEESECAKE
US$8.00
FRENCH BEIGNETS
US$7.00
CAFÉ CON LECHE
ICED CAFÉ CON LECHE
CAFÉ AMERICANO
CAFÉ CLASICO
US$3.00
CAFÉ CUBANO